Skip to content
vitrina
Sell on vitrinaSign in

How we review apps

App stores like the App Store and Shopify review apps before they go live, and Visual Studio Marketplace blocks extensions that leak keys. We do the same for every version of every app.

  1. 1One exact commitEvery version is reviewed on one commit of the seller's GitHub repository. Buyers get exactly that commit, never later unreviewed changes.
  2. 2Secrets in the codeAPI keys (Stripe, OpenAI, Anthropic, AWS, GitHub, Google and more), private keys, Supabase service_role keys and committed .env files. The rules follow the open gitleaks ruleset.
  3. 3Vulnerable and malicious dependenciesnpm packages are checked against OSV.dev, the open vulnerability database by Google and OpenSSF. Critical vulnerabilities and known malicious packages block the version. If the database can't answer, the review is incomplete, never passed.
  4. 4LicencesWe read the project's licence and its dependencies' licences. Code under GPL, AGPL or non-commercial licences can't be sold as proprietary; buyers see a summary of third-party licences.
  5. 5A person reviews itAfter the automatic checks, someone from vitrina looks at the code, the README, the listing and the demo, and approves the version or rejects it with a reason.
  6. 6Checked again every nightNew vulnerabilities are published every day. We re-check live versions nightly; if a new critical problem appears, the Verified badge goes, the seller has 14 days to fix it and buyers are told.

Why a version can be rejected

Soft rejections can be fixed and resubmitted; hard ones mean the app can't be sold as it is. Every rejection comes with reasons and one appeal.

  • R1 Incomplete (soft): It doesn't build or run, has placeholder content or a broken demo.
  • R2 Inaccurate listing (soft): Screenshots or description don't match the app.
  • R3 Security (soft): Secrets, critical vulnerabilities or missing authentication on sensitive routes.
  • R4 Documentation (soft): No install guide, environment variables or setup steps.
  • R5 Licence conflict (soft): Copyleft or unknown-licence components.
  • R6 Minimum functionality (hard): A thin wrapper, trivial app or tutorial-level code with no product value.
  • R7 Spam or duplicate (hard): Near-identical to an existing listing, or several listings for one app.
  • R8 Copycat or impersonation (hard): Clones a known product's brand, interface or name, or uses others' trademarks.
  • R9 Template output (hard): Unmodified output of an app generator or starter kit, sold as is.
  • R10 Malware or stolen code (hard): Malware, a backdoor, hidden data collection or code the seller doesn't own.
  • R11 Prohibited category (hard): Illegal content, tools to get around third-party terms, adult content or gambling.

A review is not a full security audit. It catches the most common and most dangerous mistakes in apps built quickly or with AI. Read how ranking works to see how “Verified” affects listings.